Industry brief · Shipping Costs · Margin

Shipping Rate and Transit Time Aren't Fixed Costs in 2027. They're the Lever Most Brands Aren't Pulling.

Nov 18, 2026@Phill9 min read
← The Nice Way
Quick answer

Rising ecommerce COGS in 2027 isn’t only a tariff story. Carrier surcharges, port dwell, and shipping rate and transit time add just as much, and unlike tariffs and de minimis, the shipping side is something a brand or its 3PL can still actively move. Three unrelated companies proved exactly that in the same two weeks this November, and a real client result shows what moving it looks like in practice.

Ecommerce COGS is rising in 2027 from more directions than any one brand can negotiate away. The 2027 carrier rate and surcharge stack lands inside the same six-week window whether or not a brand saw it coming. Elevated dwell times at the Port of Los Angeles are adding real cost and delay before a container even clears customs. And the end of the de minimis exemption raised landed cost industry-wide for any brand importing goods under $800: Lululemon told investors to expect a $240 million profit hit, Aritzia said a third of its trade-related headwinds came from the change, and DavidsTea reported higher costs and new shipping complexity on everything coming from Canada. None of that is a pricing mistake any of those companies made. It’s policy and carrier pricing, and neither one negotiates.

It isn’t all out of a brand’s hands, though. In the same two weeks this November, three unrelated companies each showed that a meaningful piece of 2027’s rising cost, specifically how fast and how cheaply a package actually ships, is still very much in play. UniUni started handing off some peak-season packages to other parcel carriers, Gofo among them, specifically to raise delivery density and cut cost per package. OTAA, an Australian menswear brand, moved its US fulfillment to a Cart.com facility in Texas and cut its cost to fulfill and deliver a US order by roughly half. CarParts.com grew its in-house, multi-carrier last-mile network and booked a real gross margin gain, which its CFO credited mainly to lower freight rates and carrier diversification. Three companies, three different levers, the same underlying point: shipping rate and transit time are not fixed costs. They’re decisions, and most brands are making them by default instead of on purpose.

Key terms in this piece

Two phrases come up throughout this piece and they’re worth pinning down before the rest of the argument lands. Both are Nice-defined for the 2027 conversation, not industry-standard vocabulary, and both refer to specific, active decisions a brand can still make.

  • Defined term

    The negotiable half

    The portion of a brand's shipping and fulfillment cost that it or its 3PL can still actively shape, carrier mix, fulfillment location, and rate automation, as distinct from tariffs, de minimis duties, and carrier base-rate increases, which are fixed by policy or industry-wide pricing and apply the same way regardless of who a brand ships with.

  • Defined term

    Dual-hub routing

    Splitting outbound fulfillment across two or more geographically distributed warehouses so a shipment reaches more of the country within a shorter carrier zone, cutting transit time without switching carriers or raising cost.

What’s Actually Driving Up Ecommerce COGS in 2027

Several forces are pushing 2027 COGS up at once, and none of them wait on a brand’s input. Start with trade policy: the de minimis exemption let imports under $800 enter the US free of duties and taxes, and when it ended, the effect wasn’t gradual. It landed on every brand importing goods at once, regardless of size, vertical, or how well that brand negotiates with anyone. The duty gap covers the mechanics of that change in detail, but the short version is that landed cost went up industry-wide on a single date, and no brand’s shipping strategy, carrier relationship, or 3PL contract had any bearing on whether it happened to them.

The same is true of two other pressures already loose in the system heading into 2027. USPS, Amazon, UPS, and FedEx are each raising rates and surcharges inside the same six-week window, a surcharge stack that lands whether or not a brand saw it coming. And elevated dwell times at the Port of Los Angeles are adding real cost and delay before a container even leaves the port, driven by volume and labor dynamics no single importer controls. Tariffs, carrier base-rate increases, and port congestion share one property: a brand can plan around them, but it can’t negotiate them away. That’s the ceiling. What happens underneath it is a different question.

The Half of Landed Cost You Can Still Move

Underneath the fixed ceiling, there are three levers a brand or its 3PL can still pull. Three recent, unrelated moves show what each one actually does.

Carrier mix and negotiation.

This isn’t a fringe move. ShipMatrix data shows roughly 145 million US packages shifted from the national carriers to alternative and regional carriers, including OnTrac, Veho, and Gofo, in the first half of 2026 alone, as shippers chased a lower cost per delivery. UniUni, a last-mile delivery company, is one example: it started handing off some of its peak-season packages to other parcel carriers, Gofo among them, in November 2026. The reasoning is specific: carriers often draw from the same pool of contracted drivers in a given market, and when two carriers separately assign drivers to the same neighborhood, routes overlap and each driver covers fewer parcels. Redistributing packages raises density per driver and, in UniUni’s words, these changes “reduce the cost per delivery and create a more efficient and sustainable operating model.” The lesson generalizes past any one carrier: which carrier handles a given package in a given zip code is a routing decision, not a fixed cost, and it can be renegotiated as volume and lanes shift.

Fulfillment location.

OTAA, an Australian menswear brand doing roughly half its business in the US, felt the de minimis change directly: shipping from Melbourne got meaningfully more expensive overnight. Its response was to move fulfillment, not pricing. By shifting its bestselling styles to a Cart.com facility in Longview, Texas, OTAA cut its cost to fulfill and deliver a US order by roughly half, according to its own November announcement. Cart.com’s CEO put the principle simply: a brand needs US fulfillment capacity sized to demand it has already proven, not demand it hopes for. Where a product ships from is a decision a brand and its 3PL make together, and it has a bigger effect on landed cost than most brands budget for.

Automated, diversified rate shopping.

CarParts.com took a third path: building out its own in-house, multi-carrier last-mile network for big and bulky items that otherwise trigger steep carrier surcharges. In its most recent quarter, that network’s volume roughly doubled versus the prior quarter, and the company’s interim CFO credited a real gross margin gain mainly to lower freight rates and carrier diversification, not to pricing. The CEO’s framing was blunt: the point is to “control the cost, the timing, and the customer experience” instead of accepting whatever a single carrier’s rate card says that month.

None of these three companies solved tariffs or de minimis. They didn’t try to. They moved the half of landed cost that was always theirs to move.

Editorial photo illustrating dual-hub routing, showing how splitting inventory between two geographically distributed fulfillment hubs cuts carrier zone distance and shortens transit time without changing carriers
Dual-hub routing visualized: the same brand, the same carrier mix, two fulfillment locations instead of one. Most packages now ship from inside a shorter, cheaper zone.

What This Looks Like in Practice

A good 3PL runs those same three levers on behalf of every brand in its network, continuously, instead of once a year during contract renewal. In practice, that looks like three specific capabilities working together.

Dual-hub routing means operating from more than one fulfillment location so that no single warehouse has to cover the entire country through one zone structure. A brand shipping only from one coast absorbs multi-day transit and higher zone-based rates for the half of the country on the other side of it. Splitting inventory across two hubs, one East and one West, lets most orders reach a customer within a shorter, cheaper zone regardless of where they live.

Carrier negotiation at scale means a 3PL combines volume across its entire client base, not just one brand’s shipments, when it negotiates with national and regional carriers. A single mid-sized brand rarely has enough volume on its own to move a carrier’s pricing. A 3PL shipping for dozens of brands through the same regional and national lanes does, and a 3PL that treats that leverage as part of the job, not an occasional favor, renegotiates it as volume and lanes shift rather than letting a rate card sit untouched for years.

API-driven rate shopping means every label is priced against the full carrier mix at the moment it ships, not assigned to whichever carrier’s contract is easiest to default to. A shipment that’s cheapest and fastest on a regional carrier one week might shift to a national carrier the next if volume, zone, or service levels change. Doing that by hand, label by label, doesn’t scale past a handful of orders a day. Doing it through software that checks live rates across every contracted carrier before a label prints is what makes the first two levers, multiple hubs and negotiated carrier rates, actually pay off on every order instead of just the ones somebody remembers to check manually.

None of this replaces negotiating well. It’s what makes a good negotiation worth something past the day it’s signed.

“The reason this matters in 2027 is that the four surcharge increases landing in the same six weeks already happened on the policy side. The negotiation half is what brands actually have left on the table.”

— Phill Civitella, CEO, Nice Fulfillment

A Real Example: Cutting Rate and Transit Time at the Same Time

One brand in Nice Fulfillment’s network shows what these levers look like landing on a single account. After a renegotiation with Gofo, the regional carrier, its average outbound rate on that carrier dropped by $2 per package, applied across ongoing volume rather than as a one-time promotional rate. Separately, once the brand began splitting inventory across both Nice hubs, Charleston and Salt Lake City, instead of shipping everything from one, its typical transit time on that lane fell to two days. Neither change asked the brand to do anything differently. Both came from treating carrier rate and fulfillment location as things a 3PL actively manages on a client’s behalf, not terms fixed at onboarding and left alone.

That result isn’t an outlier. It’s visible in the network data underneath it. Over the trailing 30 days across Nice Fulfillment’s full client base:

CarrierShare of volumeAvg label cost
Gofo (regional)67.1%$5.98
USPS Ground Advantage24.6%$8.49
FedEx Ground3.7%$87.20
UPS 2nd Day Air2.7%$30.37
UPS Ground1.5%$17.77
UPS Standard0.2%$21.50

FedEx Ground’s higher average reflects the larger, heavier shipments routed there by default, not FedEx’s base rates generally. The pattern that matters is the top line: the majority of volume rides a negotiated regional carrier contract at roughly a third of national ground rates, because the rate shopping happens automatically at the label level rather than defaulting to one carrier out of habit.

The same 30-day window averaged 4,026 outbound shipments, a blended average label cost of $10.89, and an on-time ship rate of 99.6% across the 3,870 shipments that carried a committed due date. Measured ship date to delivery across the full carrier mix, average delivery time was 4.9 days. Relying on USPS alone over that same period would have averaged 6.3 days, about a day and a half slower. Neither number is dramatic in isolation. Compounded across thousands of shipments a month, a day and a half of transit time and a few dollars of rate difference per package is the gap between a 3PL that’s a fixed cost and one that’s a lever.

What to Ask Your Own 3PL in 2027

These six questions separate a 3PL that’s managing the negotiable half of your landed cost from one that’s just shipping whatever the rate card hands it. Walk through them with whoever owns your fulfillment relationship before planning locks for next year.

  1. Question

    Step 01

    Ask for a true all-in cost per order.

    Including fuel surcharges and any carrier handoff fees, not a base rate quote that leaves those out.

  2. Question

    Step 02

    Ask whether your 3PL negotiates carrier contracts across its full client base.

    Not just your volume alone, and how often those contracts get revisited rather than left untouched for years.

  3. Question

    Step 03

    Ask whether your inventory is split across more than one fulfillment location.

    And what share of your orders actually land in a shorter, cheaper carrier zone as a result.

  4. Question

    Step 04

    Ask whether rate shopping happens automatically at the label level.

    Or whether it defaults to one carrier by habit, and ask to see the system that does it.

  5. Question

    Step 05

    Ask for your own on-time and transit-time data by carrier.

    Not an industry average or a carrier's own marketing claim.

  6. Question

    Step 06

    Build shipping cost and transit time into 2027 planning as a lever you manage.

    Not as a fixed assumption carried over from last year's contract.

Brands building a fuller pre-2027 plan can also walk through how to choose a 3PL from scratch, since getting this half of landed cost right starts with picking a partner who treats it as a lever instead of a line item.

Sources

The reporting behind this piece.

About the author

Phill Civitella is the CEO of Nice Fulfillment, where he has spent 18 years in fulfillment and logistics helping ecommerce brands build supply chains that hold up under real pressure, not just steady-state volume. He writes every week on The Nice Way.

Frequently asked

FAQ

  • What is the negotiable half of landed cost?

    It's the portion of what it costs to get a product to a customer that a brand or its 3PL can still actively shape: carrier mix, fulfillment location, and rate automation. It's distinct from tariffs and de minimis duties, which are fixed by policy and apply the same way regardless of who a brand ships with.

  • Why can't some of 2027's COGS increases be negotiated?

    Tariffs, de minimis duties, and carrier base-rate increases are set by trade policy or industry-wide pricing, not by any single brand's contract, and they apply to every affected brand on the same date regardless of size or leverage.

  • How does carrier negotiation actually lower shipping cost?

    A 3PL that combines shipping volume across its full client base has more leverage with national and regional carriers than any single mid-sized brand does alone, and can renegotiate rates as volume and lanes shift instead of leaving a contract untouched for years.

  • What is dual-hub routing and how does it cut transit time?

    It's splitting outbound inventory across two or more geographically distributed warehouses so more shipments reach customers within a shorter, cheaper carrier zone. In one real case, a brand leveraging both of Nice Fulfillment's hubs cut its typical transit time on a lane to two days.

  • How much can carrier and fulfillment strategy actually save a brand in 2027?

    Results vary by brand and lane, but real examples in 2026 show the range: OTAA cut its US fulfillment cost roughly in half by relocating fulfillment, and one Nice Fulfillment client cut its average rate on one carrier by $2 per package through renegotiation.

  • What should a brand ask its 3PL about rate shopping?

    Whether every label is priced against the full carrier mix automatically at the moment it ships, or whether shipments default to one carrier by habit regardless of whether that carrier is actually the cheapest or fastest option for that order.

The closing note

“2027’s COGS pressure isn’t one thing. Tariffs, carrier surcharges, and port dwell are policy and industry pricing; nobody negotiates their way out of those. But shipping rate and transit time, carrier mix, fulfillment location, and how fast a rate gets shopped, are decisions, and most brands are making them by accident instead of on purpose. The $2 and the two days in this piece came from someone actually managing those decisions instead of letting a contract sit untouched.”

— Phill Civitella, CEO, Nice Fulfillment